A playlist with 1,000 followers or 100,000 might look successful on the surface. But follower count isn’t everything.

Just because a playlist has a big following doesn’t mean people are actually listening. And if you’re a playlist curator, artist, or label trying to measure the true performance of a playlist, you need to dig deeper.

In this guide, we’ll break down how to tell if your playlist is healthy and truly delivering value to listeners and artists alike. Whether you’re growing a playlist from scratch or managing one with thousands of followers, these tips will help you spot what’s working, and what isn’t.

‍

What Does a Healthy Playlist Look Like? 

A healthy playlist consistently attracts real listeners, contributes streams to the artists it features, and keeps growing steadily over time. It’s not just about vanity metrics, true playlist success is measured by activity, discovery, and engagement.

Spotify may show you how many people follow your playlist, but it doesn’t tell you how many are actually streaming it. That’s where these deeper indicators come into play.

‍

Why Is Playlist Health Important?

If you’re curating playlists for fun, for community, or to promote artists (including your own), it’s important to know what’s actually working. A healthy playlist has the power to:

• Drive real exposure and streaming growth for artists
• Increase algorithmic visibility across Spotify
• Build listener trust, making people more likely to follow or return

On the flip side, unhealthy playlists often see stagnant growth, low engagement, and minimal streaming impact.

‍

What Affects Playlist Performance? 

Several key factors influence how healthy or successful a playlist is, including:

• Curation quality: Are the songs well-matched and thoughtfully sequenced?
• Playlist title and description: Do they help Spotify understand and rank your playlist in search?
• Cover art: Eye-catching covers can increase clicks and followers.
• Update frequency: Fresh playlists perform better in Spotify’s algorithm.
• External promotion: Are you actively sharing the playlist or relying solely on organic reach?

‍

4 Ways to Tell If Your Playlist Is Healthy 

Now it’s time to dig into the key strategies that can help you measure and improve your playlist. These four methods will give you a clear picture of how your playlist is performing and where it has room to grow: 

1. Your Playlist Is Growing Organically 

One of the best signs of a healthy playlist is steady, organic growth. This means that your playlist is gaining followers naturally through listeners recommending it to their friends, or Spotify favoring it in its search algorithms. Here’s how to track this: 

• Monitor weekly follower growth manually using a spreadsheet. 
• Use data tools like Chartmetric to keep close tabs on the trajectory. 
• If you run ads to attract listeners to your playlist, separate those results so you can measure true organic reach.

If you notice your playlist keeps growing, even without paid promotion, it’s a clear sign listeners find it valuable.

‍‍

2. Check Spotify’s “Discovered On” Section 

The “Discovered On” section (found at the bottom of artist profiles on desktop) shows which playlists are actually driving streams to an artist. To use this to evaluate your playlist: 

• Go to your playlist and select artists, focusing on lesser-known ones.
• On the artist's page, note their monthly listener count.
• ‍Check their "Discovered On" section to see where your playlist ranks.
• Begin with 5-10 artists from your playlist for better accuracy.

Here are some examples to help you better understand this metric and evaluate how your playlist is performing.

If your playlist is top-ranked (meaning in one of the first five places of the “Discovered On” section) for an artist with 1,000 monthly listeners, then you’re likely contributing about 500+ streams.

If your playlist is middle-ranked for an artist with 100,000 streams, you may be driving 1,000–2,000 of those.

Ultimately, the “Discovered On” method helps you gauge how much impact your playlist has on artist visibility and streaming volume. If you’re ranking in high places within an artist’s “Discovered On” section, this is a great way to measure the health of your playlist. 

‍

3. Use Tracker Songs for Direct Data 

Want hard numbers? Add tracker songs! This refers to a song where you (or a collaborating artist) have access to the backend Spotify for Artists data.

Here's how to use them:

• Place one tracker song in each quartile of your playlist.

For example: if your playlist has 200 tracks, put a tracker song in positions 1–50, 51–100, 101–150, and 151–200.

• Use Spotify for Artists to view weekly streams for each tracker song. 

This gives you a cross-sectional view of listener engagement across the whole playlist and not just the first ten tracks. It also helps you understand how deep listeners are scrolling and whether your playlist is keeping their attention throughout.

‍‍

4. Calculate Your Playlist Health Index (PHI)

The Playlist Health Index (PHI) is a powerful way to measure how active your playlist really is compared to its size. It goes beyond surface-level stats like follower count to give you a clearer picture of actual engagement. Here’s how to calculate it:

PHI = (Average Weekly Streams per Tracker Song) ÷ (Total Playlist Followers)

Then compare your result to the scale below:

This method helps you measure true playlist performance, regardless of follower size. A high PHI means listeners are actively engaging with tracks, while a low PHI may signal the need to refresh your playlist or improve traffic quality.

‍

Key Takeaways

• A healthy playlist doesn’t just have followers, it has real and engaged listeners.
• Organic growth is a strong signal of long-term success.
• Use Spotify’s “Discovered On” section to estimate your impact on artist streams.
• Tracker songs help provide direct engagement data across your playlist.
• Calculating your PHI reveals how active your playlist is per follower.

‍

FAQs About Playlist Health

How often should I check my playlist health?

Once a month is a good rule of thumb. Regular check-ins help you stay on top of performance trends and adjust your curation strategy.

Do playlist followers matter?

Yes, but only to a point. Follower count can show social proof, but it doesn’t always reflect engagement or active streams.

How can I get more organic growth for my playlist?

Focus on strong titles, custom playlist covers, consistent curation, and regular updates. Promote your playlist on social media, artist collaborations, and fan communities.

What tools can help me track playlist data?

Platforms like Chartmetric, Spotify for Artists, and Songtools provide deeper analytics and help you monitor follower trends and placements.

‍

If you're serious about playlist curation, whether for yourself, your label, or the artists you support, you can’t rely on surface-level stats. Follower count is just the tip of the iceberg.

By applying the methods above, you’ll get a much clearer picture of your playlist’s true performance. And with that clarity, you can make smarter decisions that grow your audience, support great artists, and build lasting engagement.

Have a playlist you’re proud of? Try these techniques and see how healthy it really is, and if you discover new insights, share them with us at social@songtools.com! We’d love to hear what’s working for you.

‍

Photo by Etactics Inc on Unsplash